Etsy to review its terms after backlash over use of artwork in AI

Etsy to review its terms after backlash over use of artwork in AI

Etsy sellers are closing their shops after the platform added a clause allowing the company and its partners to use user content to develop and train artificial intelligence technologies. Following complaints, Etsy has said it will review the terms; the new version is scheduled to take effect on December 16.

The controversy is not just about how Etsy uses artificial intelligence, but also about the breadth of the license in its terms. The company says the use is intended to improve its services and protect the platform; some creators fear their illustrations and products could end up in systems unrelated to that purpose, with no clear way to opt out.

The clause that sparked the protests

The new wording appears in section 5, subsection C, of the terms of use. It authorizes Etsy and its “partners and external service providers” to use sellers’ content to “develop, train, test, and improve” artificial intelligence and machine-learning technologies. The text cites improving services and helping keep them safe as purposes.

The update is scheduled for December 16. According to The Philadelphia Inquirer, the previous version of the terms did not include a specific clause about using content for artificial intelligence. Creative Bloq adds that the section already provided for a broad, perpetual license to reproduce, modify, distribute, and create derivative works; the change explicitly adds AI training.

The reference to external partners heightened concern. In his post, Etsy’s vice president of customer operations, James Ossman, maintained that the platform would not use the works to train models intended to copy original work or replace the creativity of the people who sell it. However, sellers and media outlets have noted that this promise is not worded in the same way in the legal clause.

“It took me years to learn and create my work. I won’t let them steal it from me.”

— Aaron Millard, illustrator

Millard’s statement appeared in an Instagram post, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer. The illustrator said he was removing a shop he had run for nearly a decade. In another message, he expressed concern that Etsy would train AI on the works and resell the data to third parties without allowing him to opt out.

AI on Etsy: What's Allowed and What's Changing — Etsy Success

Shops disappearing—and a business with 13 years on Etsy

The reaction has gone beyond complaints on social media. PC Gamer reported shop closures and farewell messages shared by sellers; Creative Bloq described illustrated posts in which artists announced they were leaving the platform. Among those who left are Kristen and Geoff Zephyrus, founders of Cognitive Surplus, a home goods and stationery brand that had sold on Etsy for 13 years.

In an Instagram post, the couple accused Etsy of claiming “perpetual, free, and unlimited” permission to train AI on their work and resell the data for profit. Kristen Zephyrus told The Philadelphia Inquirer in an interview that they wanted nothing to do with this use. The objections are not limited to individual artists: they also affect businesses that have used the marketplace to sell their products for years.

Other sellers have not yet closed their shops, but are asking customers to buy directly rather than through Etsy, according to Creative Bloq. The outlet also reported that some creators feel they cannot leave yet because they depend on the platform as their main source of income. The concern also coincides with a time of year they consider especially important for sales.

The protest comes shortly after another Etsy decision about AI. In October, the company announced stricter restrictions on AI-generated content that some users call “AI slop.” According to PC Gamer, the platform had also received praise for banning AI-generated recipes and patterns; Ossman justified this approach by saying buyers and sellers need to trust how products are presented and that human work is behind them.

What Etsy says about training and its partners

In a post addressed to sellers, Ossman described uses such as automatically translating product descriptions, displaying listing photos in marketing campaigns, and creating tools to help manage shops. Among the latter, he cited features for optimizing listings and summaries of business performance statistics.

Engadget also reported examples involving fraud detection and tools to help buyers discover products. Ossman said Etsy gives certain external partners access: according to his explanation, some provide fraud-detection services, while others help more buyers find items outside the platform. He also said Etsy prohibits unauthorized scraping of listings to train models.

The explanation has not resolved the discrepancy between the uses described by the company and the scope of the license. PC Gamer noted that the ban on extracting content without authorization does not appear to apply to Etsy or to third parties that the company itself authorizes. Creative Bloq, meanwhile, pointed out that Ossman did not specify whether an authorized partner could use sellers’ content to train models for applications unrelated to Etsy.

The possibility of opting out is also disputed. PC Gamer reported that there was no general option to opt out of training; Creative Bloq reached the same conclusion after reviewing the platform’s public explanations. The terms refer to possible opt-out rights described in the privacy policy, but those outlets did not identify a general mechanism available to sellers.

The review of the terms and the response still to come

On November 20, PC Gamer reported that Etsy had told The New York Times it intended to review the policy. The Philadelphia Inquirer reported the following day that the company would review the terms after receiving complaints. Ossman added that Etsy was working to clarify the wording and would share the revised terms soon directly with sellers.

In his message, Ossman said the company should have done a better job explaining how it uses content to help buyers discover products, support businesses, and keep the platform safe. He also said creative works belong to their authors. Engadget reported another clarification from him: Etsy does not claim the creations as its own or give others the right to do so.

The closures add to a history of clashes between the platform and some of its sellers. The Philadelphia Inquirer reported that in 2022, more than 20,000 sellers took part in a strike against a 30% increase in the basic transaction fee, from 5% to 6.5%. The current dispute, however, centers on content usage rights and the relationship between Etsy’s public promise and the wording of its terms.

The context also includes broader criticism of the kinds of products appearing on the site. Engadget noted that Etsy has faced criticism over mass-produced items shipped directly by third parties. The platform must now respond to sellers questioning an AI policy just after the company tightened its rules on certain AI-generated products.

The Philadelphia Inquirer placed the clash within a broader tension at publicly traded internet companies: pressure to adopt artificial intelligence versus user opposition. The outlet cited a Gallup poll from the summer according to which nearly 40% of Americans believe AI does more harm than good. That figure provides context for the discontent, but the decision to close a shop here is a response to a specific clause and uncertainty about how the works will be used.

For now, Etsy has promised to clarify the wording, but sellers’ reaction will depend on what the new version says and whether it changes the scope of the authorization. The current terms are still scheduled to take effect on December 16.

حالي

Sources: PC Gamer, The Philadelphia Inquirer, Engadget, Creative Bloq