GTA 6 reaches 99 on Metacritic and tops its all-time ranking

GTA 6 reaches 99 on Metacritic and tops its all-time ranking

Grand Theft Auto VI has a 99/100 on Metacritic and has climbed to the top of its all-time ranking, ahead of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. The advantage is not the score—both are listed at 99—but the number of reviews counted for each game.

The figures changed rapidly on November 18. Vandal reported that the game had 145 reviews; Wccftech counted 115 and VidaExtra, 123. The available Metacritic page later showed 153 reviews, although it does not include the average score in the content consulted. The counts reflect different points in time and a listing that was still being updated.

The number of reviews breaks the tie

The ranking reported by Vandal places GTA 6 in first place, tied with Ocarina of Time at 99 points. Metacritic ranks the game with more reviews higher: Nintendo's title has 22 reviews counted, compared with more than a hundred for Rockstar's new release.

VidaExtra also described the change as Ocarina of Time's loss of the top spot, which it had held for 28 years. In its count of 123 reviews, dozens of outlets had awarded the highest score. Metacritic's current listing confirms that the number of professional reviews has continued to grow, reaching 153.

RankGamePlatform listedScore
1Grand Theft Auto 6PS599
2The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of TimeN6499
3SoulCaliburDreamcast98
4Super Mario Galaxy 2Wii98
5Grand Theft Auto 4Xbox 36098
6Super Mario GalaxyWii97
7Grand Theft Auto 5Xbox 36097
8The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the WildNot specified97
9Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3PS297
10Perfect DarkN6497

The table reproduces the top ten published by Vandal. Its list puts GTA 4 and GTA 5 among the ten highest-rated games, alongside several Zelda titles and other classics. The platforms are listed as they appear in that ranking; Vandal does not specify a console for Breath of the Wild.

Grand Theft Auto VI: An Extended Look — Rockstar Games

Almost unanimous critical reception

The lowest score Vandal noted among the reviews counted was 90/100. The cited criticisms include a somewhat predictable narrative and restrictions on the Ultimate edition's content. Even so, most of the reviews mentioned in the published counts were outstanding, and dozens awarded a perfect score.

Vandal gave the game a 10/10 in its review. In its conclusion, it summed up the wait and the experience in these words:

Grand Theft Auto VI is a masterpiece. It is the game of our lives, the title we have had to wait 13 years for—a time in which we have grown, changed, matured, experienced joy and sadness, until reaching this moment.

— Vandal, review conclusion

Wccftech offers a more nuanced assessment: its review gave the game a 9.6 and argued that it is not a revolution, but that it makes notable improvements on several fronts. The outlet praised its emotional story, detailed world, graphics, and wide range of activities. It also described it as an evolution of the series' formula, rather than a reinvention.

This nuance matters when considering the record: the Metacritic ranking summarizes the scores of aggregated reviews, not literal unanimity on every aspect. The published material contains broad praise as well as specific reservations, although the latter have not stopped the average from remaining at 99 in the counts from Vandal, Wccftech, and VidaExtra.

The release, between the planned date and regional availability

Rockstar Games is developing and publishing the latest entry in its open-world action series. Vandal lists the planned release date as November 19, 2026, for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S, more than thirteen years after Grand Theft Auto V. The Metacritic listing consulted also includes PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X; the page does not show a PC version among the listed platforms.

Wccftech, by contrast, says the game had already officially launched in New Zealand when the review embargo lifted. The publication describes the moment as the end of a wait of 13 years, 2 months, and 1 day since GTA V. Vandal's November 19 release date and Wccftech's reference to the game's arrival in New Zealand reflect different regional contexts.

The Metacritic page consulted includes sections for critic and user reviews, but indicates that user scores are not yet available. For now, the top spot is based on professional reviews; the response from people who play the game has not yet appeared on the listing.

The score is still up in the air

The record could shift if more reviews come in or aggregated scores change. Vandal warned that the 99 could fluctuate slightly as the first wave continued, although it considered the volume already gathered enough to make the score likely to hold. Wccftech also anticipated that the average could drop somewhat in the following days.

For now, Metacritic shows 153 professional reviews for Grand Theft Auto VI, while the ranking cited by Vandal places it ahead of Ocarina of Time thanks to a much larger pool of reviews. Metacritic's listing indicates that user scores are not yet available.

Sources: Vandal, Wccftech, Vida Extra, Metacritic